Old Fashioned Custard Pie

IMG_7914   IMG_7911   IMG_7913

“Plain custard pie is a favorite of mine, and this old recipe of my Aunt Dora’s is  for a large ten-inch custard pie.  I just love it! Other recipes I’ve tried end up with a soggy crust or the filling is too low or too bland.   Sometimes the best recipes are the old ones,  and yet  sometimes I find the opposite to be true.  There are old recipes that  have been greatly improved upon through the years with new techniques or ingredients.   It depends. 

The entire dough recipe is used for this pie to give you a thick bottom crust and it is a dream to work with! It is very fixable and patchable if it breaks.It is important to chill it before using.  And you might find yourself needing more flour as you roll it than other doughs.

My technique is to roll the dough to eleven inches but roll the outer inch thinner than the rest of the dough so the crust is not as thick as the rest of the pie dough.

You can sprinkle the top of the pie filling with coconut before you bake it  if you like that. I choose a tiny sprinkling of nutmeg on top since I think it looks better than cinnamon, but if you want cinnamon on top, then just sprinkle it on during the last 10 minutes of the baking time.  Enjoy!”

Servings: 8



6 eggs
2 tablespoons vanilla extract
1 cup sugar
1 heaping tablespoon  cornstarch
3 3/4 cups milk
2 tablespoons butter

1 teaspoon nutmeg or cinnamon



2 cups flour
1 teaspoon salt
2 teaspoons sugar
1 cup butter flavored shortening
1 egg
3 tablespoons water


1. DOUGH: Mix all dough ingredients together to form a dough.
2. Shape the dough into a round 5-inch disc, wrap it in waxed paper and let it chill in the refrigerator for at least one hour.
3. FILLING: In a large bowl beat eggs and vanilla. Set aside.
4. In a small bowl mix sugar and cornstarch until well combined. Add this to the egg mixture. Set aside.
5. In a large pan over medium high heat, scald the milk and butter together.
6. Slowly add the scalded milk to the egg and sugar mixture and whisk together to blend.
7. Pour slowly into the pie shell.
8. Sprinkle the top of the filling with nutmeg. If you want to use cinnamon on top instead, sprinkle it during the last 10 minutes of the baking time.
9. Use a pie shield to cover the edges of the pie.
10. Bake at 450º for 10 minutes, then lower the oven to 400º and bake for 15-20 minutes, or until a knife inserted half-way between edge of pie and center comes out clean.
11. Cool pie on a wire rack.
12. Store pie covered in the refrigerator.

Nutritional Information:  Old Fashioned Custard Pie

Servings Per Recipe:  8 slices

Amount Per Serving: 1 slice
Calories: 555
Calories from Fat: 301

* % Daily Value *
* Total Fat 33g 51%
* Saturated Fat 11g 56%
* Cholesterol 149mg 50%
* Sodium 413mg 17%
* Total Carbohydrates 54g 18%
* Dietary Fiber 0g 0%
* Protein 10g 19%
* Sugars 30g
* Vitamin A 8%
* Vitamin C 2%
* Calcium 15%
* Iron 8%

* * Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.

Categories: Desserts, Pies

Tags: ,

4 replies

  1. Recipes received from Aunts, Moms and especially Grandmothers are always the best. I have some treasured recipes that only bring great memories. Your pie sounds delicious and thank you Aunt Dora 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • You brought a smile to my face and one even wider when I saw your “Aunt” in your name! So true about those old treasured recipes and the memories! Thanks for your kind words. 🙂


  2. To Sinfully Tempting: Happy you agree with me Jeannette, that some old recipes just cannot be improved upon! 🙂


  3. Angie, this pie is amazing. I love the old-fashioned pies that have held their own throughout the years. Just more proof that some things don’t need to be changed! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Making and creating


If I knew you were coming I'd have baked a cake...

The WordPress.com Blog

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

Brooklyn Homemaker

modern classic recipes, story telling, and a little bit of history. Oh yeah, and schnauzers.

City Boy Hens

Stepping Back To A Simpler Time!

I'm Frayed Knot

Original Crochet Designs

Angie's Open Recipe Box

Favorite Recipes Tried and True, Old and New

Simply Made Kitchen and Crafts

Wholesome family living, simple recipes and crafts

Ann Carmen Collection

One of a kind handmade jewelry created by Ann Carmen

Lynne Pusscat - Quilting Junkie

An English quilter in Switzerland

Coinquilini in Cucina

"Uno non può pensare bene, amare bene, dormire bene, se non ha mangiato bene." Virginia Woolf

Goan Recipes

Learn about Goan and Indian Recipes


A fine WordPress.com site

Cooking Is My Sport

Practice makes perfect.

Selma's Table

Life doesn't have to be perfect to be wonderful - stories and recipes from a wonderful life...

Fae's Twist & Tango

Magazine of a Storyteller... articles about world cultures, travel, and recipes with a twist and tango ♪ ♪ ♪ ...

Sugar and Spice Baking

And all the yummy things we are making…

My Foray Into Food Storage

A regular gal learning about Food Storage, Home Cooking, Canning, Gardening, and more!

Cookies Cakes Pies Oh My

...and Everything Else I Love to Bake!


Colourful Good Food & Positive Lifestyle

a whisk and a spoon

connoisseur of fine cake

Mikey's In My Kitchen

Cooking For An Inspirational Eater

food on fifth

recipes from a food stylists kitchen

tea and sesame

British-born-Chinese foodie, traveller and business woman

gotta get baked

musings of a baking fiend

ice cream magazine

................... for lovers of ice cream. Your free on line magazine for sweet frozen treats. Recipes, inspiration, artisanal ideas for your delectation.

Little Sweet Baker

Simple and delicious recipes for today's busy lifestyle.

Rantings of an Amateur Chef

Food...cooking...eating....tools - What works, and what doesn't!

the quiet baker

Everyday food adventures, creations, and life around Vancouver


Food is beautiful!


A sweet WordPress.com site

Cooking with Mr Fitz

A collection of food journeys & taste-full experiences

Sweet And Crumby

Baking, a Love Story

%d bloggers like this: